European Commission President Ursula Von der Leyen said talks on Horizon would begin immediately once the Windsor agreement was implemented (file image)
By Pallab Ghosh
Science correspondent
BBC News understands a deal for the UK’s association with the EU’s €100bn (£85bn) Horizon research and innovation programme has been negotiated.
The proposed arrangement is awaiting approval from the prime minister.
If Rishi Sunak agrees, an announcement is expected on Tuesday after his talks with the European Commission chief Ursula von der Leyen.
The official government position is that talks are still ongoing and that no deal has been agreed.
But highly placed sources have now told BBC News that a sticking point over how much research funding the UK is expected to receive has been resolved and that two separate options for associate membership await the prime minister’s consideration.
Mr Sunak has been said to be enthusiastic about an alternative, UK-led, international collaborative research programme, drawn up by the Science Minister, George Freeman. But the UK research community has constantly and unanimously argued for membership of the European Horizon programme.
If Mr Sunak rejects the options on his desk the anger from the scientific establishment will be ”unimaginable”, according to a senior scientific leader.
Should events go as expected, the deal will come as a huge relief to the scientific community. Many of the UK’s leading researchers have been left in limbo over the future of their world-leading research projects and in some cases their own jobs and those of their teams.
Image source, Getty Images
Nobel prize winner Sir Paul Nurse: “Prime minister should finalise the deal without further delay”
Associate membership had been agreed as part of the withdrawal agreement when the UK formally left the EU at the end of January 2020. But the arrangement was not activated because of a disagreement over the Northern Ireland protocol. This was resolved in February of this year and it had been hoped that a deal for Horizon would swiftly follow.
The EU waived the UK’s joining fee for the time it had not been a member, but it stuck to the arrangement agreed with former Prime Minister Boris Johnson’s government about the funding the UK would be expected to receive.
The government had agreed that if UK researchers received less than 12% of what than the UK put in, Britain could terminate the arrangement. The figure for other associate members of Horizon is 8%, but it was thought to be a price worth paying for continuing to be part of the programme by the government at the time.
Talks since the Windsor agreement have focussed largely on renegotiating this figure to be more in line with that of other associate members. It is understood that two formulae have now been agreed between the UK and EU, which await the prime minister’s signature.
The stand-off has bemused UK researchers because pre-Brexit the UK received around £500m more than the £1.5bn a year it put in. For Horizon the government has agreed to pay approximately £2bn a year and given the quality of British science, the research community believes it would get at least the same amount back. Many feel that months have been lost haggling over a hypothetical point.
News that a draft agreement had been reached was reported on Wednesday afternoon by Politico, but was greeted by a terse statement from the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office.
“Talks are ongoing and therefore, we have not yet agreed a deal.”
Image source, Getty Images
The UK has some of the best scientists in the world. Some have moved to an EU institution because of uncertainty over Horizon
The statement went on to say that the report did not “reflect current state of negotiations”, and that “UK participation in EU programmes must be fair for UK researchers, businesses and taxpayers, and we have set out our bold, ambitious alternative, Pioneer, if we’re not able to secure association on that basis”.
James Wilsdon, a professor of science policy at University College London, told BBC News what while this was “wonderful news” the uncertainty over the past three years had “blighted” UK-EU scientific collaboration.
“In haggling over the budget, the UK was in danger of being penny wise but pound foolish — emphasising short-term costs over the huge long-term gains that will flow from UK participation.
“Hopefully a compromise has now been reached and the research community can move forward with the clarity and commitment that it has been crying out for.”
Professor Lord Krebs, a long-serving and respected scientific adviser to the government from the University of Oxford, said: “Delays over two years have caused serious and lasting damage to UK R&D.”
Nobel prize winner Sir Paul Nurse said the prime minister should finalise the deal “without further delay”, a view echoed by Prof Sarah Main, executive director of Campaign for Science and Engineering.
“I urge the prime minister and President of the European Commission to secure this agreement, enabling researchers to get on with the vital role they play in improving people’s lives and livelihoods,” she said.
The UK is also seeking to rejoin the Copernicus Earth observation programme.
